Spice Up Your Hotty Toddy: 6 Different Ways To Make A Southern Classic

While no one may know where the term Hotty Toddy came from, it certainly has blossomed in a variety of cultural aspects for Ole Miss – one of which happens to be how to make a proper drink.

A generations-old cold remedy, the Hotty Toddy usually consisted of a cup of black tea with a teaspoon of honey, squeeze of a lemon and a splash of bourbon – all to be taken right before bed.

But now, thanks to the internet, dozens of variations now exist for the southern staple.

With so many choices which ones are actually worth your money? Glad you asked. We have the answers with these six different ways to make a Hotty Toddy drink.

Traditional Hotty Toddy

Did your mama ever tell you “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it?” That’s exactly why the classic recipe makes the list. If you’re gonna make an experimental Hotty Toddy, you better know how the original tastes – and Catch 88 provided us with the perfect one.

hotty toddy drink recipes

Pumpkin Spice Hotty Toddy

People are freaks about pumpkin spice during autumn, so it shouldn’t come as a shock that there’s a version of it for the Hotty Toddy.

Grab the recipe courtesy of Sugar Crafter here. 

Pumpkin Spice Hotty Toddy

Fireball Hotty Toddy

In case you can’t stomach real whiskey or bourbon just yet, add in the ever-popular choice of Fireball for a cinnamon kick.

Grab the recipe from Six One Six here. 

Fireball Hotty Toddy

Caramel Apple Hotty Toddy

If the traditional Hotty Toddy is already a 10 in your book, just call this Caramel Apple version the hot cousin that visits occasionally. This recipe is for those who prefer not to have a fruity liqueur in their drink, but rather enjoy the authentic caramel-apple taste added as a compliment.

Grab the recipe from The Cookie Rookie here.

Caramel Apple Hotty Toddy

Spiced Apple Hotty Toddy With Cinnamon Sugar Rim

Suckers are born every minute, and while this recipe’s only difference from the aforementioned recipes is that it has a cinnamon sugar rim, we’re pretty sure most of us are a go for that little added perk.

Grab the recipe from Celebrations at Home here. 

Spiced Apple Hotty Toddy With Cinnamon Sugar Rim

Sweet Tea Hotty Toddy

Two staples in the South are whiskey and sweet tea. And anytime you add the two together, you’ve got a winning recipe.

Grab the recipe from A Beautiful Mess here. 

Sweet Tea Hotty Toddy